Compliancemanzill.com
ISO/IEC 23894:2023

ISO/IEC 23894:2023/Framework/4 of 34

5.4.1Understanding the organization and its context

Control family: Framework

Control description

The guidance provided in ISO 31000:2018, 5.4.1 applies.

In addition to guidance provided in ISO 31000:2018, 5.4.1, Table 2 lists additional factors to consider when understanding the external context of an organization.

Table 2 — Consideration when establishing the external context of an organization

Organizations should additionally consider, but not exclusively, the following elements:

The social, cultural, political, legal, regulatory, financial, technological, economic and environmental factors, whether international, national, regional or local:

- Relevant legal requirements, including those specifically relating to AI.

- Guidelines on ethical use and design of AI and automated systems issued by government-related groups, regulators, standardization bodies, civil society, academia and industry associations.

- Domain-specific guidelines and frameworks related to AI.

Key drivers and trends affecting the objectives of the organization:

- Technology trends and advancements in the various areas of AI.

- Societal and political implications of the deployment of AI systems, including guidance from social sciences.

External stakeholders’ relationships, perceptions, values, needs and expectations:

- Stakeholder perceptions, which can be affected by issues such as lack of transparency (also referred to as opaqueness) of AI systems or biased AI systems.

- Stakeholder expectations on the availability of specific AI-based solutions and the means by which the AI models are made available (e.g. through a user interface, software development kit).

Contractual relationships and commitments:

- How the use of AI, especially AI systems using continuous learning, can affect the ability of the organization to meet contractual obligations and guarantees. Consequently, organizations should carefully consider the scope of relevant contracts.

- Contractual relationships during the design and production of AI systems and services. For example, ownership and usage rights of test and training data should be considered when provided by third parties.

The complexity of networks and dependencies:

- The use of AI can increase the complexity of networks and dependencies.

(guidance beyond ISO 31000:2018):

- An AI system can replace an existing system and, in such a case, an assessment of the risk benefits and risk transfers of an AI system versus the existing system can be undertaken, considering safety, environmental, social, technical and financial issues associated with the implementation of the AI system.

In addition to guidance provided in ISO 31000:2018, 5.4.1, Table 3 lists additional factors to consider when understanding the internal context of an organization.

Table 3 — Consideration when establishing the internal context of an organization

Organizations should additionally consider, but not exclusively, the following elements:

The organization’s culture:

- The effect that an AI system can have on the organization’s culture by shifting and introducing new responsibilities, roles and tasks.

Standards, guidelines and models adopted by the organization:

- Any additional international, regional, national and local standards and guidelines that are imposed by the use of AI systems.

Capabilities, understood in terms of resources and knowledge (e.g. capital, time, people, intellectual property, processes, systems and technologies):

- The additional risks to organizational knowledge related to transparency and explainability of AI systems.

- The use of AI systems can result in changes to the number of human resources needed to realize a certain capability, or in a variation of the type of resources needed, for instance, deskilling or loss of expertise where human decision-making is increasingly supported by AI systems.

- The specific knowledge in AI technologies and data science required to develop and use AI systems.

- The availability of AI tools, platforms and libraries can enable the development of AI systems without there being a full understanding of the technology, its limitations and potential pitfalls.

- The potential for AI to raise issues and opportunities related to intellectual property for specific AI systems. Organizations should consider their own intellectual property in this area and ways that intellectual property can affect transparency, security and the ability to collaborate with stakeholders, to determine whether any steps should be taken.

Data, information systems and information flows:

- AI systems can be used to automate, optimize and enhance data handling.

- As consumers of data, additional quality and completeness constraints on data and information can be imposed by AI systems.

Relationships with internal stakeholders, taking into account their perceptions and values:

- Stakeholder perception, which can be affected by issues such as lack of transparency of AI systems or biased AI systems.

- Stakeholder needs and expectations can be satisfied to a greater extent by specific AI systems.

- The need for stakeholders to be educated on capabilities, failure modes and failure management of AI systems.

Contractual relationships and commitments:

- Stakeholder perception, which can be affected by different challenges associated with AI systems such as potential lack of transparency and unfairness.

- Stakeholder needs and expectations can be satisfied by specific AI systems.

- The need for stakeholders to be educated on capabilities, failure modes and failure management of AI systems.

- Stakeholders’ expectations of privacy, and individual and collective fundamental rights and freedoms.

Interdependencies and interconnections:

- The use of AI systems can increase the complexity of interdependencies and interconnections.

In addition to the guidance provided in ISO 31000:2018, 5.4.1, organizations should consider that the use of AI systems can increase the need for specialized training.

How to implement

Coming in phase 2Step-by-step guidance for implementing this control on Microsoft Azure, using services such as Azure Policy, Microsoft Defender for Cloud and Entra ID. It will be matched to your environment.